Open Prompt Revision
When my peers commented on the first draft of this essay, they had a couple constructive pieces of feedback. In the introductory paragraph, my weak attempt at humor just served to confuse, so I changed that, and separated the exposition into a separate paragraph detailing the most obvious meanings of the red tent. They also said I had a pretty wimpy conclusions, largely due to the fact that I ran out of time, so I added some more connecting details that rounded out my conclusion and essay.
1970 Choose a work of recognized literary merit in which a specific inanimate object (e.g., a seashell, a handkerchief, a painting) is important, and write an essay in which you show how two or three of the purposes the object serves are related to one another.
Anita Diamant's novel The Red Tent is a retelling of the biblical
story of Dinah, daughter of Jacob. In this book, a specific inanimate
object stands as a refuge for Dinah and her mothers, a connection to
their ancestors, and a symbol of womanhood.You guessed it, the Red Tent!
Every new moon, the wives of Jacob enter the red tent for their monthly
cycle. According to their culture, women were to be separated from men
during this time.When Dinah comes of age, she is accepted into the red
tent as a young woman. Here, the fertile women spend three days in
peace; resting, praying, and singing. The red tent, in the tribe of
Jacob, was the symbol for womanhood and fertility.
In a patriarch-dominated society, the red tent symbolized refuge from
demanding and sometimes cruel men. Ruti, "whose eyes seemed permanently
blackened, was the slave-wife of brutish Laban. She found sanctuary in
the few days of the month that she spent in the red tent, where Laban
could not follow her. Even for the wives with gentler husbands, women
were expected to submit completely to their husbands, and could not talk
and joke freely in the presence of men, "In their day along in the red
tend, Jacob's wives spoke among themselves about their husband's dreams
and plans". It was also here that they were able to plot without being
overhear. When the tribe of Jacob choose to leave Laban, his daughters
steal from him his idols (gods), to take with them to their new home.
Leah hides them in the red tent. Laban searches for them everywhere
except, "his eyes fixed upon the women's tent on the edge of the camp.
It was unthinkable that a healthy man would walk inside that place
during the head of the month, among bleeding women - even worse, his own
daughters". The taboo of the tent protects them from intrusions; and
makes trespasses all the more horrible. Once his idols have been
"polluted beyond redemption" by laying in the tent, he believes their
magic to protect him is lost, and he never bothers his daughters again.
As well as being an oasis in a patriarchal world, the red tent is a
place for passing on stories. These are the women's tales; being the
only daughter of Jacob, Dinah "heard all the stories from her
mother and mother-aunts, which her brothers wouldn't be bothered to hear
or pass on". Dinah's aunt Bilhah tells her the story of how man first
learned to spin wool into thread, and Rachael tells the stories of the
births she has midwifed. Along with personal stories, the red tent is a
place where Jacob's wives carry on traditions from their grandmothers
and great-grandmothers, "The women sang all the welcoming songs while
Rachael made fine wheat-flour cake in the three-cornered shape of
woman's sex". The make sacrifices to their goddesses and welcome Dinah
into the red tent with the traditional ceremony, "they put kohl on my
eyes, and perfumed my forehead...painted my arms and legs with henna".
The red tent is a place for the women's traditions to be carried on.
The red tent literally symbolizes the isolation of menstruating women,
but within, it is a place for Jacob's wives to escape the controlling
men of their time, and share their personal histories and traditions.The strong feminine connotations of this object connect it to the
goddesses who Jacob's wives worship, and make Laban's trespass more shocking and invasive. The red tent is the women's domain where they can speak freely and pass on stories to their daughters. The red tent is a very important object with many meanings.
I think this essay is a lot more clear and easy to follow, and I really liked how you used examples and actual quotes from the story. Your conclusion is also very well done because it wraps up the whole essay and it makes a connection. The only change I think you should make is in the introduction, I think you shoudl make the last sentence of your intro more of a theisis rather than saying "You guessed it, the Red Tent!"
ReplyDeleteComparing the first and second post, it's very similar, but I can see what you changed. One thing I disagree with Neha is that you used quotes. I personally thought that these prompts were ones that were used for the actual AP Exam. If this is the case, I don't think we are given the choice to take in all the novels and books we need for the essay. Weaving quotes definitely makes the writing a lot stronger, but I don't think it's a good idea to use when we're practicing for the Exam. However, I do really like your new revisions. The conclusion wraps the whole essay better than before. Especially by using anaphora in your concluding sentences, it gives off the riddle tone you have in the introduction.
ReplyDelete